By Professor Satya Narayan Misra* in Bhubaneswar, November 16, 2026: Sonia Gandhi’s recently published autobiography “Belonging: A Journey of Love” has created several controversies; one of them being, the way she has tried to show Dr Pranab Mukherjee in a poor light by sharing a conversation where Dr Mukherjee expressed a desire to become PM in 2010. Having seen Dr Mukherjee closely as a financial advisor when he was Rakshya Mantri (RM), I can vouchsafe for the fact that he had all the credentials, gravitas, and intellectual heft to become the PM.
Dr Manmohan Singh, who was Sonia’s choice as PM, served under Dr Mukherji as RBI Governor, when he was chosen by Indira Gandhi as FM (1984-1986). He was respected by all cabinet colleagues as he helmed many GoMs & by the MPs of all opposition parties.
Unlike Indira Gandhi who fully trusted Pranab, Sonia deeply distrusted Dr Murkhejee. He served as the Defence Minister from 2004-2006, showing exceptional competence & skirted all controversies & sleazy deals that shrouded defence procurement by putting in place transparent procurement processes and procedure.
He was aware how the image of the Congress under Rajiv was severely besmirched by allegation of graft in the Boffers deal, which prompted his dear friend from Doon Arun Singh to resign from the Defence Ministry. He was also aware of the looming presence of Quattrrarocchi, the Italian middle man, in defence procurement & his proximity to Sonia.
Transparency in Defence Procurement
One of the first visitors to him in Defence Ministry in 2004 was Sri N. Vittal, the Central Vigilance Commissioner, who harped on the need to put in place a transparent procurement process in defence deals. This showed the seeds of Defence Procurement Manual (DPM -2005)which catapulted India’s image as a transparent buyer of defence goods. This was followed by Defence Procurement Procedure (DPP-2005) for capital acquisition of weapon systems and platforms, which assured global suppliers of India as a transparent buyer.
There was a clear message against engagement of defence agents and harsh blacklisting provisions, should there be any discovery of such involvement of agents. Dr. Mukherjee also put in place a new procedure called the ‘Offset Procedure’ in 2005, which encouraged transfer of key technology, FDI & outsourcing of orders to Indian producers by major OEMs ( Original Equipment Manufacturers) in big ticket orders.
As India ranked very high on the Corruption Index by the Transparency International, we introduced a provision where both the buyer and seller would sign a “Commitment for No Corruption”, with an oversight agency like CVC monitoring corruption complaints. Dr.Mukherjee had the foresight to ensure that under the cover of security and strategic requirements, defence procurement must notskirt fair process, equal opportunity and transparent criteria for shortlisting, evaluation of vendors& award of contract. The legacy that he left behind as DPM & DPP are still being practiced by the Modi government, with minor modification
Fond Association with Indira
I recall when we had gone to attend the Golden Jubilee Celebration of HMI at Darjeeling in 2006; we were stranded on the Lebong airstrip because of an inclement weather. He was in expansive mood. While sipping tea served by an army jawan from the nearby army detachment, he shared how he was once similarly stranded along with Mrs. Gandhi in 1973 when Sanjay Gandhi accompanied her. He recounted how Sanjay was playing pranks with the jawans and Mrs. Gandhi was getting up constantly to dissuade him from being naughty.
Pranab told her “Madam, let him play; this is his age to play and have fun”. When I reminded Dr. Mukherjee of the major pranks that Sanjay had played on people’s personal lives of people during emergency; he smiled and parried the question and got into a reflective mood. He shared how Mrs. Gandhi told him that after she lost the election in 1977, how almost everyone had deserted her.
Dr. Mukherjee has written in his Memoirs about her ignorance of the constitutional provision of Article 352 for imposing internal emergency, till Siddharth Shankar Ray clarified it to her. He has also recounted how Sri P.V. Narasimha Rao, admonished him for leaving Congress hurriedly and forming an alternative party because of his differences with Rajiv. PVR really liked and trusted Pranab as he brought him as his Foreign Minister, when he became PM in 1991. I saw PVR once briefly. They were like pea and pod; erudite, cerebral and acceptable across the political spectrum.
Sonia’s Uncharitable Take
Pranab Mukherjee was very unhappy when he was shifted by Sonia to External Affairs Ministry & brought in Anthony, a Sonia loyalist. She was possibly discomfited by the independent manner in which Pranab ran the Defence Ministry & finalised major defence deals. He loved to travel by the Embraer aircraft purchased by the Defence Ministry and loved to read books during such long travels. Though he posts graduated in economics, Indian Constitution was his specialisation and favourite port of call.
He recalled precedents like the back of his palm. Nehru was hisoriginal hero, as he discovered the Parliamentarian in him; Indira was his weakness, as she catapulted him to the position of FM, when he was a callow 49. Rajiv & Sonia as perpetuators of dynasty, distrusted him defenestrated him from the richly deserving position of PM.
In 2004 he missed the honour, as Sonia unlike Indira did not trust him & preferred a loyalist like Manmohan Singh as PM, who will carry her writ unconditionally. Sonia has been very cagey about independent minded leaders like PVR & Pranab. Margaret Alva, a senior Congress leader, in her autobiography “Courage & Commitment” recalls with bitterness how PVR’s mortal remains were stopped outside the party headquarter, and his cremation denied in Delhi, ostensibly at the behest of Sonia. These unfortunate facets to Sonia’s personality, her distrust & pettiness towards independent minded leaders like Pranab, and PVR, somewhat blights her political odyssey in India and ‘journey of love’ .
*The writer worked with Dr Mukherjee from (2004-2006)


Leave a Reply
Be the First to Comment!